Oh both are so beautiful!!! Like someone wrote, the choice is completely up to you but I have a feeling you will get this one here. :) They are so similar. Wow. I had the same thing happen to me, not planned at all. I have been heartbroken over losing my girl 4th of July 2016 and then this year a friend called to tell me of a 5 wk old puppy that was dropped off abandoned in her apartment complex she just moved to an hour from me. I didn't ask questions but felt bad for the pup, and said I was not ready yet. (I have a 14 y.o. dog Bella still here and didn't want her to feel jealous). This was on 7-7-2017. My friend said okay and would keep trying to find someone to take her. She sent me a pic and well...the pup looked very similar to my girl who left me even down to the white tip on her black tale like my girl had! So I said I would take her but had work the next day. Well, my work got cancelled the next morning so I instead picked up the adorable pup on 7-8-2017. I felt it was meant to be. She has been weat addition although a handful! She has even done some of the same things my last girl did , even drawn to Ginger's area of the yard, even hopped up to knock down all Ginger's old stuffed animals when I left her alone the 1st two times for me to come back with her sleeping in the box she knocked over with all the stuffed animals bigger than her surrounding her lol. I have no idea who she could have even hopped that high as tiny as she was when I first got her? I feel they even have the same eyes and she loves to stare at me as she sleeps just like Gingi did. I always said my Gingi was my soulmate and now I have to wonder how all this stuff works. So many have asked if I have watched A Dog's Purpose. I am still not ready though. I will say though I know the jist of the movie and if anyone could try to get back to me somehow it would be my Gingi. I named the new pup Daisy. Both black and white, both pit bulls. Both extremely lovable. I wasn't looking but I am happy I got her. I know she could never ever replace my Gingi and I will miss Ginger til the day I die. And Daisy is very different in some ways and so similar in others, even with kissing herself as she walks past the mirror like Gingi uses to. I wish you the best in making the best decision. :) Some dog will be very lucky to have you help them out.
Denise (Sweet Ginger's Mom)